Should I Buy a Co-Sleeper or Cot Bed? The Best Sleeping Option for Your Baby

When you’re expecting, one of the most exciting (and sometimes overwhelming) parts of preparing for your baby is getting the nursery ready. From choosing the right furniture to picking out baby clothes, there’s a lot to think about. One of the key decisions to make is where your baby will sleep in the early months: should you buy a co-sleeper or a cot bed? Both options have their pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your family’s lifestyle, your preferences, and the space available.

In this guide, we’ll explore the differences between co-sleepers and cot beds, their benefits and drawbacks, and how they relate to your antenatal care and preparations for a safe and comfortable baby experience. Whether you’re looking for a safe sleep environment or simply trying to decide what’s best for your little one, this article will help you make an informed choice.

What is a Co-Sleeper?

A co-sleeper is a type of crib that attaches to the side of your bed, allowing you to sleep close to your baby while keeping them in their own safe sleep space. This option is popular among parents who want to practice safe co-sleeping, allowing for easier night-time feeds, bonding, and comfort.

Co-sleepers are designed to be safe and secure, with a low side that gives you easy access to your baby, while still providing a barrier to prevent them from rolling out. They are often adjustable in height to fit different bed frames and come with features like breathable mesh sides for ventilation.

Pros of a Co-Sleeper

Easy access for night-time feeding: If you’re planning to breastfeed, a co-sleeper can make middle-of-the-night feedings much easier since you don’t need to get out of bed to pick up your baby.

Promotes bonding: Being close to your baby while they sleep allows for greater bonding. The closeness can be comforting for both parents and babies, especially in the early days of parenthood.

Safe co-sleeping option: Co-sleeping can be controversial, but a properly designed co-sleeper is a safe option to keep your baby close without the risks associated with bed-sharing.

Convenience for parents: Parents often find it easier to comfort their babies during the night in a co-sleeper, especially if the baby is having difficulty settling.

Cons of a Co-Sleeper

Space limitations: Co-sleepers can be small and may not accommodate your baby for long. Depending on how quickly your baby grows, you might need to transition to a larger bed sooner than expected.

Limited lifespan: Most co-sleepers are designed for babies up to around 6 months old, so you will likely need to buy another sleeping arrangement later on.

Not suitable for all bed setups: If you have a very high bed or a platform bed without a traditional bed frame, finding a co-sleeper that fits your setup can be challenging.

What is a Cot Bed?

A cot bed is a standalone crib that can be used from birth until your child is around 2 to 3 years old, depending on the size and features of the cot. Cot beds often convert into toddler beds once your baby outgrows them, making them a longer-lasting investment compared to co-sleepers. Cot beds come in a variety of sizes, designs, and materials, so you can find one that matches your nursery and fits your space.

Some cot beds come with adjustable mattress heights, allowing you to start with a higher position for easier access to your baby and then lower it as they grow and become more mobile.

Pros of a Cot Bed

Longevity: Cot beds generally last longer than co-sleepers, often converting into toddler beds. This means you won’t need to buy another bed for your child until they’re older.

More space: Cot beds provide more space for your baby to sleep and move around, which can be particularly helpful if your baby is a restless sleeper.

Greater flexibility: Cot beds come in different sizes and designs, and many models include adjustable mattress heights, making them a flexible choice as your baby grows.

A dedicated sleep space: A cot bed gives your baby a designated sleep area, which can help them get used to the idea of sleeping independently.

Cons of a Cot Bed

Less convenient for night-time feeding: If you plan to breastfeed, a cot bed might not be as convenient as a co-sleeper since you’ll need to get up to feed your baby.

Takes up more space: Cot beds are generally larger and may require more space in your nursery. This might be a consideration if you have a small room.

Price: Cot beds tend to be more expensive than co-sleepers, especially if you opt for one with more features, like a conversion to a toddler bed.

Co-Sleeper vs Cot Bed: Which is Right for You?

Deciding between a co-sleeper and a cot bed is a personal choice, and it often depends on several factors, such as your space, your parenting style, and how long you plan to keep your baby in the same sleep space. Let’s break down a few key considerations to help you make the decision:

Space Availability

If you have a smaller bedroom or are limited on space, a co-sleeper might be the best option. It attaches to your bed, taking up minimal room but providing your baby with their own safe sleep space. A cot bed, while more spacious, may be better suited for a larger nursery, where it can become a permanent fixture for several years.

Convenience and Night-time Care

For antenatal care and planning, convenience plays a big role. If you’re looking for an easy way to care for your baby during the night, a co-sleeper allows you to easily reach your baby for nighttime feeds, changes, and comforting without leaving the bed. If you prefer to have your baby in their own space, then a cot bed may be a better fit, though you’ll need to get up during night-time feeds.

Safety and Sleep Training

When it comes to safety, a cot bed is a clear winner for many parents who want their baby to have their own designated sleeping area from the start. Cot beds are larger and often come with more advanced safety features, such as adjustable mattress heights and convertible designs. Antenatal support often suggests that having your baby sleep independently in a cot may help with sleep training later on, but this depends on the family dynamic.

If you’re keen to practice co-sleeping, a co-sleeper is a great middle ground. It allows you to sleep close to your baby while still ensuring they have a safe space to sleep. However, always make sure that the co-sleeper is attached securely to the side of your bed and that there’s no risk of the baby rolling out.

Budget Considerations

When it comes to cost, co-sleepers are generally more affordable than cot beds, though this may vary depending on brand and features. If you’re on a tight budget or are unsure whether you want to co-sleep or use a cot, starting with a co-sleeper can be a practical choice. Remember, you may need to purchase a cot later, which will add to the cost.

Long-term Use

If you’re planning on using the bed for several years, a cot bed may be the better investment. Many cot beds can be converted into toddler beds, giving you more value for your money. Co-sleepers, on the other hand, are often only used for the first 6 months, making them a shorter-term solution.

What the Experts Say

The NHS provides helpful guidance on safe sleep practices for babies, including advice on the risks of bed-sharing and the importance of having a safe sleep space for your baby. They recommend safe co-sleeping with a co-sleeper as a safer alternative to bed-sharing. However, always consult your antenatal care provider for personalised advice.

Both co-sleepers and cot beds have their advantages and drawbacks. A co-sleeper is a great choice for parents who want the convenience of having their baby close by during the night while ensuring their baby is safe in their own sleeping space. On the other hand, a cot bed offers long-term benefits, lasting for several years and providing a designated sleep space for your growing baby.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your lifestyle, your preferences, and your space. Speak with your antenatal support team to help guide your decision, and always prioritise the safety and comfort of your baby.